Cherry Picking Sofa - 12 March 2010 05:14 PM

Brendan - 12 March 2010 04:09 PM

The (SLE) Ballerina - 12 March 2010 02:35 PM

I think last night shows that a dominant C team should be higher than a middle of the road A team. (Skeets over slapers / SLE over danza)

Keep in mind that a couple upsets in a 270 game season might not be solid justification for the inadequacies of a ranking system.

 

Not to quabble nor puff the Skeets up as grander than they are, but it should be noted that SLE and Skeets are a combined 16-1-1 with a week left where they will face each other.  They are also a combined 2-0 vs. A teams and 2-0 v. B teams.  And 2-0 vs. D teams.  The one loss came of these two teams was in a short-handed game.  So, perhaps Ballerina’s conclusion isn’t based on a “couple upsets”.  I haven’t seen all the scores yet, but I did note that another C team tied an A team and that a D team beat a B team.

I’m pretty sure Danza was very short-handed, last night.

Fidel Assthrow - 12 March 2010 05:40 PM

Cherry Picking Sofa - 12 March 2010 05:14 PM

Brendan - 12 March 2010 04:09 PM

The (SLE) Ballerina - 12 March 2010 02:35 PM

I think last night shows that a dominant C team should be higher than a middle of the road A team. (Skeets over slapers / SLE over danza)

Keep in mind that a couple upsets in a 270 game season might not be solid justification for the inadequacies of a ranking system.

 

Not to quabble nor puff the Skeets up as grander than they are, but it should be noted that SLE and Skeets are a combined 16-1-1 with a week left where they will face each other.  They are also a combined 2-0 vs. A teams and 2-0 v. B teams.  And 2-0 vs. D teams.  The one loss came of these two teams was in a short-handed game.  So, perhaps Ballerina’s conclusion isn’t based on a “couple upsets”.  I haven’t seen all the scores yet, but I did note that another C team tied an A team and that a D team beat a B team.

I’m pretty sure Danza was very short-handed, last night.

I’m certain the Skeets were short-handed last night.

Whatever, you had all of your best players there.  I watched the match. Short-handed, my ass.  Who was missing?  Ziggy? 
 
Nice work, though.

Ziggy and Jason.  We played 7.  That’s short-handed.

Fidel Assthrow - 12 March 2010 05:45 PM

I watched the match. 
 

How’d you stay awake?

Fidel Assthrow - 12 March 2010 05:40 PM

Cherry Picking Sofa - 12 March 2010 05:14 PM

Brendan - 12 March 2010 04:09 PM

The (SLE) Ballerina - 12 March 2010 02:35 PM

I think last night shows that a dominant C team should be higher than a middle of the road A team. (Skeets over slapers / SLE over danza)

Keep in mind that a couple upsets in a 270 game season might not be solid justification for the inadequacies of a ranking system.

 

Not to quabble nor puff the Skeets up as grander than they are, but it should be noted that SLE and Skeets are a combined 16-1-1 with a week left where they will face each other.  They are also a combined 2-0 vs. A teams and 2-0 v. B teams.  And 2-0 vs. D teams.  The one loss came of these two teams was in a short-handed game.  So, perhaps Ballerina’s conclusion isn’t based on a “couple upsets”.  I haven’t seen all the scores yet, but I did note that another C team tied an A team and that a D team beat a B team.

I’m pretty sure Danza was very short-handed, last night.

What??  Joe Re played for Danza…

Ah, that’s the “pretty sure” part.  I thought Joe was primary SLE.

Fidel Assthrow - 14 March 2010 01:13 PM

Ah, that’s the “pretty sure” part.  I thought Joe was primary SLE.

We had 5 people missing - Corey, Deirdre, Ashley, Neil, and Jay.

Poison Mindy - 14 March 2010 09:13 PM

Fidel Assthrow - 14 March 2010 01:13 PM

Ah, that’s the “pretty sure” part.  I thought Joe was primary SLE.

We had 5 people missing - Corey, Deirdre, Ashley, Neil, and Jay.

what are you saying?

Lucha The Entertainer - 14 March 2010 10:08 PM

Poison Mindy - 14 March 2010 09:13 PM

Fidel Assthrow - 14 March 2010 01:13 PM

Ah, that’s the “pretty sure” part.  I thought Joe was primary SLE.

We had 5 people missing - Corey, Deirdre, Ashley, Neil, and Jay.

what are you saying?

We had 5 people missing - Corey, Deirdre, Ashley, Neil, and Jay.

After some additional discussion & review, it seems like the weighted * weight option got the most positive reaction. One flaw (or feature, depending on your point of view) is that teams with 0 wins and 0 ties get 0 points and falls to dead last in the rankings. So, I’ve made some modifications that address this flawture.

WEIGHTED * WEIGHT (same as on page 1, just reposted here for easier comparison)

01. A: Dodgy $tyle - 252
02. B: Mt. Hoodlums - 182.5
03. A: Decepticons - 180
03. A: Ricardo Montalballs - 180
05. A: Extravadanza - 174
06. B: Blood Bath & Beyond - 155
07. A: Negative Reinforcement - 150
07. A: Dodgedamnit - 150
09. C: SLE - 144
10. C: SKEET! SKEET! SKEET! - 136
11. A: Mama Said Knock You Out - 129
12. B: Dwayne’s World - 125
13. B: Independents - 115
14. A: Dodgy Slappers - 93
15. D: Hit for Brains - 90
16. D: Kill Screen - 81
17. D: Team FOB - 72
18. B: Six Degrees of Fidel - 65
19. C: The Dark Knights - 64
20. B: Ligers - 62.5
21. C: Kegelmasters - 60
22. C: Great Balls of Fire - 56
23. C: Sponsored by Winning - 52
24. C: 5150 - 48
24. D: Army of Darkness - 48
26. B: Dazed and Confused - 45
27. D: Reinheitsgebot - 42
28. D: BJ Jazzy Jeff and the Fresh Princesses - 40.5
29. E: Off Constantly - 34
30. E: The Hustlers - 30
31. D: Dodgeball Furies - 27
32. B: Dodge This - 25
33. E: Balls to the Wall - 22
34. E: Raging Ballz - 20
35. D: Foodfighters - 19.5
36. E: Tacos - 16
36. E: Detox / Retox - 16
38. C: Fight or Flight - 12
39. E: The Slores - 10
39. E: CLIND - 10
39. F: Group Shower - 10
42. D: AARP - 9
43. F: We’re Kind of a Big Deal - 8.5
44. E: Los Low Blows - 8
44. F: Nunchuck Fury - 8
46. F: TBD - 5
46. F: Bearheart - 5
48. F: Chickens on a Chain - 4.5
49. E: Speed Team - 4
49. F: Cheaters - 4
51. F: The Death Panel - 3
52. F: I’d Hit That - 1
52. F: All That Glitters Ain’t Gold - 1
54. D: Salmon Nation - 0

(WEIGHTED + WEIGHT) * WEIGHT

01. A: Dodgy $tyle - 288
02. A: Decepticons - 216
02. A: Ricardo Montalballs - 216
04. A: Extravadanza - 210
05. B: Mt. Hoodlums - 207.5
06. A: Negative Reinforcement - 186
06. A: Dodgedamnit - 186
08. B: Blood Bath & Beyond - 180
09. A: Mama Said Knock You Out - 165
10. C: SLE - 160
11. C: SKEET! SKEET! SKEET! - 152
12. B: Dwayne’s World - 150
13. B: Independents - 140
14. A: Dodgy Slappers - 129
15. D: Hit for Brains - 99
16. B: Six Degrees of Fidel - 90
16. D: Kill Screen - 90
18. B: Ligers - 87.5
19. D: Team FOB - 81
20. C: The Dark Knights - 80
21. C: Kegelmasters - 76
22. C: Great Balls of Fire - 72
23. B: Dazed and Confused - 70
24. C: Sponsored by Winning - 68
25. C: 5150 - 64
26. D: Army of Darkness - 57
27. D: Reinheitsgebot - 51
28. B: Dodge This - 50
29. D: BJ Jazzy Jeff and the Fresh Princesses - 49.5
30. E: Off Constantly - 38
31. D: Dodgeball Furies - 36
32. E: The Hustlers - 34
33. D: Foodfighters - 28.5
34. C: Fight or Flight - 28
35. E: Balls to the Wall - 26
36. E: Raging Ballz - 24
37. E: Tacos - 20
37. E: Detox / Retox - 20
39. D: AARP - 18
40. E: The Slores - 14
40. E: CLIND - 14
42. E: Los Low Blows - 12
43. F: Group Shower - 11
44. F: We’re Kind of a Big Deal - 9.5
45. D: Salmon Nation - 9
45. F: Nunchuck Fury - 9
47. E: Speed Team - 8
48. F: TBD - 6
48. F: Bearheart - 6
50. F: Chickens on a Chain - 5.5
51. F: Cheaters - 5
52. F: The Death Panel - 4
53. F: I’d Hit That - 2
53. F: All That Glitters Ain’t Gold - 2

(WEIGHTED * WEIGHT) + WEIGHT

01. A: Dodgy $tyle - 258
02. B: Mt. Hoodlums - 187.5
03. A: Decepticons - 186
03. A: Ricardo Montalballs - 186
05. A: Extravadanza - 180
06. B: Blood Bath & Beyond - 160
07. A: Negative Reinforcement - 156
07. A: Dodgedamnit - 156
09. C: SLE - 148
10. C: SKEET! SKEET! SKEET! - 140
11. A: Mama Said Knock You Out - 135
12. B: Dwayne’s World - 130
13. B: Independents - 120
14. A: Dodgy Slappers - 99
15. D: Hit for Brains - 93
16. D: Kill Screen - 84
17. D: Team FOB - 75
18. B: Six Degrees of Fidel - 70
19. C: The Dark Knights - 68
20. B: Ligers - 67.5
21. C: Kegelmasters - 64
22. C: Great Balls of Fire - 60
23. C: Sponsored by Winning - 56
24. C: 5150 - 52
25. D: Army of Darkness - 51
26. B: Dazed and Confused - 50
27. D: Reinheitsgebot - 45
28. D: BJ Jazzy Jeff and the Fresh Princesses - 43.5
29. E: Off Constantly - 36
30. E: The Hustlers - 32
31. B: Dodge This - 30
31. D: Dodgeball Furies - 30
33. E: Balls to the Wall - 24
34. D: Foodfighters - 22.5
35. E: Raging Ballz - 22
36. E: Tacos - 18
36. E: Detox / Retox - 18
38. C: Fight or Flight - 16
39. D: AARP - 12
39. E: The Slores - 12
39. E: CLIND - 12
42. F: Group Shower - 11
43. E: Los Low Blows - 10
44. F: We’re Kind of a Big Deal - 9.5
45. F: Nunchuck Fury - 9
46. E: Speed Team - 6
46. F: TBD - 6
46. F: Bearheart - 6
49. F: Chickens on a Chain - 5.5
50. F: Cheaters - 5
51. F: The Death Panel - 4
52. D: Salmon Nation - 3
53. F: I’d Hit That - 2
53. F: All That Glitters Ain’t Gold - 2

This makes a lot more sense to me.  The Slappers are almost winless, this season.  If they won zero games, they would still thunderfuck Bearheart.